When the Dow makes headlines for a big point swing, what might the percentage move tell you that the headline doesn’t? On this episode of the Retire Sooner Podcast, Wes Moss and Christa DiBiase put stock market volatility in historical context, explain how colleges use FAFSA information to help determine eligibility for college financial aid, and follow one couple as they weigh whether part-time work could fit their retirement plans after both were laid off.
In this episode:
In This Episode
- Put Dow swings in perspective by comparing points with historical percentage moves, and consider how market volatility might influence investing decisions.
- Compare dividend stocks and bonds as sources of retirement income alongside income ETFs, and weigh the trade-offs between yield, diversification, and growth potential.
- Examine what backs a corporate cash program, a government money market fund, and an FDIC-insured bank deposit.
- Compare collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) with cash holdings, focusing on how floating rates and credit risk may influence that comparison.
- Decode the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) to see how income and assets factor into the Student Aid Index and how colleges use that index to help determine financial aid eligibility.
- Explore how FAFSA treats parent-owned and grandparent-owned 529 plans and where potential state tax benefits fit into college savings.
- Compare annual giving with bunching donations through a donor-advised fund, and see how Roth and traditional 401(k) contributions differ in their effect on taxable income.
- Spot concentration risk in the S&P 500, and compare how equal-weight, sector, and international ETFs might change portfolio exposure.
- Explore Financial Independence, Retire Early (FIRE) through a couple considering Coast FIRE or Barista FIRE after a dual layoff, as they weigh potential part-time income, $80,000 in current annual spending, and future healthcare and college costs.
- Consider how time with family and friends fits into retirement planning, a theme Wes explores in The Retire Sooner Method.
Listen to the full episode and subscribe to the Retire Sooner Podcast for more listener Q&A on investing, college savings, and retirement planning.
Full Episode Transcript
Click here to read the full transcript
Wes Moss [00:00:01]: Hi, Christa, DiBiase, us.
Christa DiBiase [00:00:03]: Last week you talked about the stock market like it’s a bungee cord back and forth.
Wes Moss [00:00:08]: Yeah, we kind of had a reverse bungee cord.
Christa DiBiase [00:00:10]: And we’re still seeing a lot of volatility. And so you’ve got some follow-up research you’ve done on this.
Wes Moss [00:00:16]: We dug into big point swings and wanted to see is, and think about this, is the market, feels like it, is the market more volatile today than it’s been? Over the course of history.
Christa DiBiase [00:00:27]: And then lots of parents filling out the FAFSA right now.
Wes Moss [00:00:32]: Yes.
Christa DiBiase [00:00:33]: Financial aid for students, figuring out college, figuring out how to pay for college because students are getting accepted into colleges and, and trying to figure out where they’re going. And you have some information on that specifically for parents and grandparents and what counts, what doesn’t count.
Wes Moss [00:00:48]: Right. Well, how, how do we get student aid? Is it the college? Is it the income? Is it your assets? Who owns the assets? It is kind of a black box and I want to dig into that.
Christa DiBiase [00:00:58]: A great resource. And we of course have lots of questions that have come in for you, Wes, at wesmoss.com/ask.
Wes Moss [00:01:06]: Big swings, same things. That’s how I think about this. We’ve had some really big point moves in and some percentage moves. After the midterm elections, I know we’ve already talked a little bit about this, but you know, up 1,500, down 1,800 or almost 2,000 points. I mean, that kind of makes the hair stand up on the back of your neck. I don’t care who you are. Those are uncomfortable days in your, for your 401, for most people. Some people are so focused on the long-term.
Wes Moss [00:01:37]: They have a high risk tolerance. It doesn’t bother them, which is really a great trait to be an investor. But most of us have a human element that kicks in whether we want to or not. And, and big movements in markets. can really be unsettling. And we went back over the last couple of days, our, our research investment committee, to see just how volatile things have gotten. Now we know they’ve, they’ve gotten more volatile on a point standpoint, particularly when we’re looking at the Dow. Now the NASDAQ nominally is way higher than it’s been, the S&P 500 as well, but the Dow in that 50,000 range, the point swings are dramatic.
Wes Moss [00:02:17]: When we get 1,000-point swing, it may sound like a really big deal and much higher than we saw 10 and 20 and 50 years ago. But the percentage moves, that’s really what matters. Mm-hmm. So I wanted to see, are our percentage moves a whole lot different today than they used to be? So our team did this research. The Dow’s long-run average daily move in a percentage term, which is what matters, is about I’m going to round this. It’s 0.72 of a percent. So 3/4 of a percent, but let’s call it about 0.75 of a percent. At 52,000, that means that a normal average day is 375 points.
Wes Moss [00:03:01]: So almost 400 points is really what is a typical day for a move in the Dow Jones. So what’s interesting though, if you take it back, and this is why it feels so dramatic, Christa, that if you take that back to the 2010s, when the Dow was around 17,000, that same 375-point move would’ve been a, you know, again, that today that’s less than 1%. It would’ve been more than 2%. Go back to the 2000s when the Dow was around 10,000, it would be an almost 4% move. Go back to the 1980s when the Dow averaged, by the way, 1,500. Today, we’re getting, we’re over 50,000. The Dow averaged 1,500 points. So a, a 375-point move then in the ’80s would’ve been a 25% move in a day.
Wes Moss [00:03:51]: Go back to the 1960s, 1965, the Dow was only at 900.
Christa DiBiase [00:03:54]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:03:55]: So a point that big would’ve been almost half.
Christa DiBiase [00:03:57]: Sure.
Wes Moss [00:03:57]: In any given day. And we remember that the longer we’ve been investing, the bigger these point swings feel. But if you go back and look at market moves on a percentage basis, which really matters, 1918 to 1929, plenty of volatility there. Average move, daily move was 0.75%. Today, if I looked at 2020 to 2025, 0.79%, almost exactly the same. So even though I think today feels like bigger Swings, and they are numbers-wise, but it’s really, we’re getting the same things that we’ve gotten over the course of about 100 years of stock market history. So before you let a big number shake your confidence and make you nervous, remember, put those points in percentage terms. That’s what matters.
Wes Moss [00:04:49]: And from our research, it’s very clear that those percentage moves have been about the same. Now, yes, we’ve had a couple years where it’s more than that. But that’s about a normal year, even though it may feel like a lot.
Christa DiBiase [00:05:02]: So this may be a silly question, an obvious one, but when the last couple of weeks when this starts happening, how much do your calls go up from clients?
Wes Moss [00:05:12]: It depends. I think that there was a lot of nervousness around midterm elections because if your political party lost, you feel like, oh, this is just not going to turn out well. And I remind those folks that when they call and say, oh, the world’s going to hell in a handbasket, I say, just remember, there’s another even bigger group of the country that is really excited. But at the same time, politics should not be an investment policy, even though it’s an emotional thing for folks.
Christa DiBiase [00:05:48]: Yeah.
Wes Moss [00:05:49]: And, and then you put on top of that Giant point swings, bungee cord markets, and the worry around artificial intelligence and that buildout. Is it slowing down? And that’s really what has been on people’s minds. Not so much politics in itself, but the economic state of the future.
Christa DiBiase [00:06:08]: Okay. Well, I have some questions for you from listeners, Wes. Michaela in Arizona says, one of my goals in investing is to try to create a level of dividend income that will essentially first cover all my expenses, And second, replace my W-2 income. I recognize those two are not the same. In doing this, I’ve paid a lot of attention to dividend payout percentages as I’ve been trying to figure out what to invest in. I noticed that there are stocks that have large dividend percentages, 6%, 8%, and even 10%, yet people knowledgeable in investing warn to steer clear of them because odds are the business is struggling and that company and the high dividend payout won’t last very long. Okay, so what about a high dividend stock index? The so-called high dividend index funds only have a dividend percentage of 2%. That doesn’t seem high at all.
Christa DiBiase [00:06:57]: It only seems average. Why is that? And why can’t we find high dividend indexes that actually have high dividend percentages? Do I have to direct index a bunch of stocks with high dividends to get decent diversification?
Wes Moss [00:07:12]: Raquel, what a— I love this goal because I mean, how great is it to just have dividends pay for everything? I mean, that is a, I think it’s a very admirable and a smart goal as an investor. We know that humans are better about spending income. They feel very guilty about spending principal, even if it’s something gross. So we don’t wanna touch the principal, right? We’re all still scared of the principal.
Christa DiBiase [00:07:35]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:07:35]: So I think it’s really important to generate income and it’s a great feeling to have a steady dividend. from a stock that you also expect to grow, also pay the bills and give you a steady cash flow. I love that. So it’s a really, it’s a smart goal to have, but Mikhail, we’re in an interesting period of time. Ironically, the amount of cash that’s paid out in total dividends is an aggregate is at an all-time high. The percentage dividend yield is almost at an, let’s call it very close to an all-time low.
Christa DiBiase [00:08:10]: Hmm.
Wes Moss [00:08:11]: That’s because stock markets in general, equity markets in general, have done well from an appreciation standpoint. And on a percentage basis, because stocks have gone up near, you know, close to all our all-time highs as we speak here today, that means it dry— even though it’s the same amount or even slightly more income than last year and the year before and the year before, on a percentage basis, It seems almost unattractive. Now the S&P 500 is close to a paltry 1% dividend yield. If you look at a dividend grower ETF, I’m not going to name any names of ETFs. You’re right. You’re going to find 2%, which doesn’t sound like a lot, but on a relative basis, it’s 100% more than the S&P 500. And investing is very much about a rel— on a relative basis. Now, if you keep searching, You don’t have to go too far to find higher dividend ETFs that would limit technology companies that typically pay almost nothing.
Wes Moss [00:09:09]: And you’re going to find more utility companies, energy companies, financial companies inside of higher dividend-paying ETFs. You can find 3.5% to 4% without stretching all that far. So that dividend yield, what you’re giving up is high growth companies, but it’s not all that hard to find 3.5% to 4%. And that I think gets you closer to what you’re looking for. If you get into the 7% and 8% range, if it’s a one stock, then you’re starting to gamble.
Christa DiBiase [00:09:39]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:09:40]: There are derivative ETFs that are set up that do use options that are really set up to pay out more current income. And you kind of give up your appreciation and those can work and they’re in the 7% and 8% range. So don’t think of Remember the, the income ladder. Don’t think of one rung solving your problem. Think of multiple rungs. And oh, by the way, we don’t have time. We’re going to go to another question, but don’t forget about fixed income or bonds that are paying closer to the 5% range.
Christa DiBiase [00:10:09]: Okay. William in Arkansas says, my father-in-law is 89 years old and recently moved into an assisted living facility. As a result, my wife and I have assumed responsibility for managing his finances, including his income and expenses. After considerable effort, we recently gained access to an account called Ford Interest Advantage. My father-in-law retired from Ford Motor Company and contributed funds from his paycheck to this account throughout his career. Upon reviewing the account, we discovered it currently holds more than $800,000 and is earning approximately 4% annually. Our primary concern is that the account’s terms and conditions state in multiple places and bold print that the funds are not FDIC insured. Given his age and circumstances, we would like to explore options that may provide better protection for his assets while continuing to meet his financial needs.
Wes Moss [00:10:59]: William in Arkansas. So if you’re thinking about any money market, which any money market, if you get a prospectus, it’s going to have on every page, not FDIC insured, not FDIC insured. So that doesn’t concern me here at all. The money market, they are securities. And however, what’s inside a money market typically are ultra high quality bonds. They are typically government bonds that are, they’re very short term. So even though they may not be FDIC insured, the investments inside are extraordinarily high stability. So a money market fund to have $800,000 in, I don’t think is unsafe at all.
Wes Moss [00:11:41]: However, Mm-hmm. There’s a big however here. When companies have their own situation, and Ford is a really good example of this. From my understanding, this is a money— yes, a money market-like vehicle, but it’s actually backed by one company. And do we think that Ford Motor Company, great legendary company, but do you think they have the same credit rating as the US Treasury or US Treasury bond? which by the way is about, is AA+. I don’t know exactly what Ford’s credit rating is, but it’s probably something more like B or B-. So you have this weird situation where you’ve got what’s perceived as a money market, but it’s really backed by a, a bond that is not a super high credit, not low credit. And it’s not, these are, it’s not a junk bond, but nothing like what you would find inside a traditional money market fund.
Wes Moss [00:12:39]: So the simple answer here is to find a real money market fund. That is, and money market funds come in lots of different flavors. If you want to make sure it’s as safe as can be, find a government money market fund or a, a money, a treasury money market fund, which by the way, I’ll pay you right around that same amount. You’re just not loaning money to one company.
Christa DiBiase [00:13:00]: Okay. This came in from Tag in Connecticut. Can you discuss
Wes Moss [00:13:05]: Okay. Tag.
Christa DiBiase [00:13:06]: Can you discuss CLOs as possible dry powder options? Many of these offer 5% returns and near-zero risk since they’re A-rated loans. And Tag lists a few of them. Seem like reasonable alternatives to bonds that have seen a 15% drop with the rise in interest rates.
Wes Moss [00:13:24]: So Tag, here’s one. The answer is mostly yes, but there are a lot of different flavors of CLOs, collateralized loan obligations. The one reason that they have held up well when rates have risen is that they’re floating rate. So you don’t really have a whole lot of interest rate risk. So the whole seesaw paradigm of rates going up, your bond prices going down, that doesn’t really apply here because the CLO, essentially the rate of the borrower that they’re lending to the company is just going to pay a little bit higher as rates go up, just like an adjustable rate mortgage. So you kind of take away the interest rate risk and that’s helpful. The other part here is that if you’re looking at CLOs, they do come in a lot of different flavors. There’s A-rated and there’s B-rated and there’s C-rated.
Wes Moss [00:14:12]: The AA, they have the highest credit rating. There’s typically a lot of diversification because there may be 100 or 200 different loans inside. An A-rated ETF that holds CLOs. So you’re right, there’s not a ton of risk. These are what the big difference here for a CLO is. They are, they are for the most part securitized debt, senior securitized debt, meaning there’s the company that’s borrowing the money is pledging something of real value assets. And that makes the, A, the default potentially lower, and B, the recovery if there is a default lower. Particularly for the highest tranche.
Wes Moss [00:14:52]: And that’s if you’re looking at A-rated, you’re right. I would consider these as part— if you’re looking at the, the highest quality CLOs, they are in the dry powder camp.
Christa DiBiase [00:15:04]: Okay, excellent. So we’re going to take a quick break. When we come back, we’re going to discuss paying for college.
Wes Moss [00:15:10]: Gulp. This Thanksgiving, when you’re sitting around the table, take a look around. Because after studying thousands of retirees, I found the happiest ones aren’t just doing things. They’re doing things with people, cooking with, traveling with, laughing with. We’re in the middle of a friendship recession in this country. In my new book, The Retire Sooner Method, I’ll show you ways to fight back and build the connections that make for happy retirees. Pick up your copy today on Amazon or your local bookstore. This topic, I think, was your idea.
Christa DiBiase [00:15:48]: We were talking about paying for college, the FAFSA application a lot of parents are filling out, how to put money into 529 strategically, what else counts toward financial aid, toward student assets, parent assets.
Wes Moss [00:16:03]: And this is on my mind because I’ve got, I have, I was just on a college visit recently with one of my sons. sons, who’s a junior. So I’ve been, I think I’ve been talking a lot about school stuff, financial aid, because it’s, it’s obviously on my mind, uh, as a parent. And I wanted to go through a little bit of the details. So the FAFSA, the Free Application for Student Financial Aid, uh, that we all apply to for colleges, families do to get some sort of financial aid, is a little bit of a black box because there’s so many variables and they all have their own different weighting on how much aid you qualify for, which is the SAI. It’s the Student Aid Index. The FAFSA produces one number and it’s the SAI. And that’s the important— that is essentially what they believe you should be able to contribute.
Christa DiBiase [00:16:50]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:16:50]: The SAI is them saying, here’s what we think you can pay. This is your capacity. And then the school’s price, which by the way has no bearing on this whatsoever, is That’s the price tag. And then the difference is what you’re going to end up having to pay if you choose that school. So that’s what the FAFSA is trying to determine. Think of it this way. If the school is $10,000 and your SAI is $10,000, your financial need according to them is zero for that school. If the school’s $50,000 and your SAI is $10,000, then your need is $40K.
Wes Moss [00:17:25]: Now, of course, it doesn’t mean that the school can provide that whole amount.
Christa DiBiase [00:17:31]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:17:31]: Not all of these get funded at 100%, but that’s where your, the financial conversation really starts for that school. Now they look at 4 things and they’re all pretty obvious, but they all have different weightings. Parent income is, is really the biggest meter mover on determining your SAI, then your assets or the parent assets, then the student income, and then student debt. assets. That’s really how they look at this. And the formula subtracts some allowances. So you’re allowed to make— the government says, or FAFSA says, well, there’s a certain amount minimum you’ve got to live on. And they account for that plus some taxes.
Wes Moss [00:18:12]: And then they start giving you a calculation on the rest of your income. And it starts counting— your income starts counting against you or counting against you if you’re trying to get financial aid or that SAI over about $45,000. So I did a bunch of different calculations on this family scenario. You think, are they going to get a decent SAI or not? So, um, parent income treated after allowances, they start at counting up to 22% of it, and then it rises to 47% of it. Assets, parent assets count about 3 to 6 cents on the dollar, depending on how much you have. Student income, they’re going to— I’m rounding on here. It counts a lot against getting an SAI amount, but the first approximately $12K is excluded.
Christa DiBiase [00:19:02]: Which most students probably aren’t making more than that.
Wes Moss [00:19:04]: Exactly.
Christa DiBiase [00:19:04]: Are you going to go through what counts as parent assets as well?
Wes Moss [00:19:07]: Yes.
Christa DiBiase [00:19:08]: Okay, great.
Wes Moss [00:19:08]: Uh, and then student assets are counted at about 20%, so that can move the meter a bunch. So think of it this way, and I did the Smith family and the Jones family as 2 different examples. The Smith family has income of $75K, brokerage assets of $30K, um, no 529s, $300K in 401, $250K home equity. They would get about $4,000. They would have $4,000 worth of SAI, which means that that’s what FAFSA says you should be able to contribute, which is not a big number, meaning you would get a lot of aid. So if you had a, a school that is $50K, your need would be $46K. On the other side of the equation, the Joneses, everyone loves the Joneses, has $250K in income, $500K in brokerage, $150K in parent-owned 529s because they count. Grandparent 529s do not count.
Christa DiBiase [00:20:03]: Hmm.
Wes Moss [00:20:03]: That’s interesting. Um, and, uh, and $1 million in 401, but guess what? It doesn’t matter. It doesn’t count. So retirement accounts don’t count. Home equity doesn’t count. Grandparent-owned 529s don’t count. But the estimated SAI, hey, we think you can contribute, the Joneses, $95K. So if they’re going to a school that’s $50K, it’s way more than $50K, they get zero.
Christa DiBiase [00:20:31]: Okay.
Wes Moss [00:20:31]: Estimated need is zero. So cash brokerage, yes, counted. Investment real estate, by the way, is counted. Parent-owned 529, count it. Uh, student-owned 529 counted. Grandparent-owned 529 not counted. Home equity excluded. 401, IRA, Roth not counted.
Wes Moss [00:20:51]: So, the reality here is that, how do you plan for this? I think one of the big things to be able to plan for, Christa, is think about either taking IRA— and by the way, they’re looking at 2 years prior. Kind of like IRMAA does.
Christa DiBiase [00:21:07]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:21:08]: So think of if you have a big capital gain in that year, that can really mess up how much that could increase what FAFSA says your contribution should be. So be careful about that as your kids are a couple years out from school. If you have, take a big capital gain and sell a stock that you might not otherwise do, that could make it really hard for you to have, that could lower the amount of perceived financial aid you might get. So be careful, just like with IRMAA for Medicare, FAFSA’s looking at your income and your assets from 2 years prior.
Christa DiBiase [00:21:43]: So quick question I know we’ve gotten from listeners too. If you know, okay, I’m not going to qualify for financial aid, my student won’t. If you’re saving in a 529, when do you stop? Like what’s, how do you determine that? What do you tell your clients?
Wes Moss [00:21:57]: Well, in the real world, practically, When do you, how, how often do people fully fund college with 529s? Some people do it, but the reality is I always think of it as a really nice supplement. So I think if you can pay for a third or 30, 40, maybe 50% of college through 529, that’s usually for most people, that’s about as much as you can do.
Christa DiBiase [00:22:18]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:22:19]: But you and I’ve had this conversation where if, if you’re getting a state tax deduction to put money in a 529 plan and you know you’re going to be spending the money anyway, Why not contribute it to the 529, get the state tax deduction, and then you’re using the 529 money to pay anyway. So there’s some tax advantages to doing it. So even though you, it may only be in there for a couple months, it still may be worth it to make some contributions.
Christa DiBiase [00:22:46]: Okay. You ready for questions?
Wes Moss [00:22:48]: Yes. Let’s do it. All right.
Christa DiBiase [00:22:49]: Q&A. Scott in Colorado said, each year we end up owing between $3,000 and $5,000 when we file our taxes. Our charitable giving is just below the standard deduction. So itemizing doesn’t currently benefit us. I’m trying to figure out whether this strategy is valid and effective. At the end of this year, we would open a donor-advised fund or a similar charitable giving account and make a large contribution from our savings, enough to cover next year’s charitable giving. That larger one-time donation would allow us to itemize deductions for this year. Then at the start of next year, we would switch our 401 contributions from Roth to traditional, which would reduce our taxable income for that year.
Christa DiBiase [00:23:29]: Our charitable giving for that year would be paid out of donor-advised funds, and the money we would normally donate would simply go back into savings. We would repeat this every other year, make a large charitable contribution and switch to traditional 401 contributions in those years while still maintaining our regular charitable giving annually. With this alternating year approach, bunching charitable contributions, switching Roth to traditional, actually reduce our tax liability in a meaningful way? And is it allowed under current tax rules? Last year our AGI was $208,000 and we had to pay an additional $4,000.
Wes Moss [00:24:06]: Okay, Scott in Colorado, this is, again, this is a very serious tax question and it’s going to be different for everyone. So I don’t know if this works exactly for everyone, but if in your, in your situation, I think it works. Now, obviously you’ve got to talk to a CPA and do these calculations, but here’s why it could work. Um, and I’ve thought about this and I’ve looked at some of these numbers. You’re talking about charitable bunching. And if you think about what, what Scott is saying, if you happen to have a pretty high income, like you, you have a high income over $208,000, and you’re giving about what I would consider is probably about $30K because it’s just under the standard deduction. So I’m just assuming that. So So, standard deductions, let’s call it $34,000, approximately rounding numbers, and you’re probably giving $30,000.
Wes Moss [00:24:58]: So, giving away $30,000 doesn’t help you with your deductions because the standard deduction is already higher than that.
Christa DiBiase [00:25:04]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:25:05]: So, this is smart. He goes, well, wait a minute. I know I’m going to give away that $30K anyway. Well, if I do one year, I stack it or I bunch it and I do 2 years’ worth of charitable giving in 1 year into the DAF. So, you can put in $60K. Well, now that is more than the standard deduction. So, you get a big tax benefit in the year you do the DAF, the donor advised fund, because you’ve done 2 years in 1. Then the next year, you go back to the standard deduction because you already have cash.
Wes Moss [00:25:38]: You’ve, you gave $30K of it the first year. You should have $30K left. So, now, You’re still able to do the charitable contribution, but you got the big deduction in that one year. And again, this is hypothetical. I’ve looked at some of these numbers in the past. In your situation, the way I think about this is it— I’ve seen it be able to help people save on federal taxes. Not every state this works for. And I don’t know about Colorado, but federal at this level, double stacking.
Wes Moss [00:26:09]: the DAF at this level could save you $5,000 over 2 years, $2,500 in federal taxes, then that’s a big deal. Now it could be different for everyone. I would say if everything remains exactly in a vacuum the way it is, which again, the real world rarely ever works that way, it could save you some taxation. Definitely talk to your CPA about it. Now, one last thing, and I always want to make sure people understand this. People very often say, I owe an extra $2,000 or $3,000, or I got back another $2,000 or $3,000. Just remember your refund or whether you owe money has nothing to do with your tax rate. Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:26:47]: It’s basically, did you overpay throughout the year or did you underpay? It doesn’t change your tax rate. And I think that often gets confused, but again, I like the, I very much like the idea, Scott, of charitable bunching. Or stacking.
Christa DiBiase [00:27:02]: This one came in from Michael in Minnesota. As of late, the S&P 500 is looking like only 10 companies are driving the fund while the other 490 have not been doing so well. I keep hearing that if an AI crash or bubble burst were to happen, we could see a 30% market correction. I’m semi-retired in the green zone, but I would not want this correction to happen because we’ve invested heavily in the S&P 500. We thought it was diverse. Is there a recommendation to invest in an ETF fund that could separate the AI flyers and the other 409 companies? We totally love your show.
Wes Moss [00:27:35]: Well, I totally love that you’re listening. It’s been a while since we got one of these questions. This has been the same thing, man, for a long time. Like it’s been, the concentration in the S&P 500 has been very high in a few names for a long time. And it’s, it’s arguably gotten even Steeper. If you look at the 10 biggest companies, it’s 38, 39% of the index. And 8 of the 10 of those companies are tech. And it’s the bottom 2, it’s number 9 and 10 that aren’t tech.
Wes Moss [00:28:07]: So the top 8 are tech. Uh, that’s where we get the Mag 7, by the way, the big tech companies in the United States. And you’re right. If you own S&P 500, you really own 40% of your assets are in those 10 stocks. That’s just the way the market capitalization works. And it’s really easy to get unconcentrated, very easy to do that. And one, there are S&P 500 funds or ETFs that are what are called equal weight. So they weight every stock the same.
Wes Moss [00:28:39]: So you don’t get an overweighting in tech. There are sector funds that you can think about. There’s very low on a percentage basis. Utilities is a tiny percentage of the S&P 500. So you barely get any utility exposure if you own the S&P 500. Energy, believe it or not, that’s a really small percentage too. Hmm. Uh, real estate REITs, really low percentage.
Wes Moss [00:29:02]: So what would you do? You would, and obviously that, and including international companies or international ETFs, indexes, adding any of those other areas that are underrepresented in the S&P 500 would almost automatically help give you less concentration to one particular sector.
Christa DiBiase [00:29:24]: Okay. Kevin in New Jersey says, my wife, who’s 44, and I, 45, recently hit a major plot twist. We were both laid off from the same company at the same time.
Wes Moss [00:29:36]: What?
Christa DiBiase [00:29:36]: We have 2 kiddos, ages 9 and 7, in a suburban medium cost of living/high cost of living area. While a dual layoff sounds like a nightmare on paper, it has us questioning whether we even need to jump back into the full-time corporate grind Or if we’re ready for some flavor of FIRE. Here is our financial snapshot. Total invested liquid assets, $2 million. A taxable brokerage has $950,000. Our retirement accounts have $850,000. HSA has $50,000. And cash emergency fund has $150,000.
Christa DiBiase [00:30:13]: And they have $100,000 in a 529. That’s not counted in their total assets. And their mortgage, $300,000 remaining on a 2.97% fixed rate, not paying it off early. Our annual spending is $80,000 a year inclusive of our mortgage payment. My back-of-the-envelope math suggests that with $2 million invested and $80K burn rate, our liquid brokerage can bridge us through the years while taking on lower stress or just part-time work to cover basic living costs. Our retirement accounts will be left untouched and compounding will do its work before age 60. However, a CFP friend of mine insists we aren’t even close to any version of FIRE given 2 kids in this medium-high cost of living area and the cost of healthcare and college ahead. Who is right here? Are we within striking distance of Coast Barista FIRE, or am I suffering from the classic spreadsheet brain and ignoring real-life friction?
Wes Moss [00:31:10]: What a plot twist. 2 layoffs at the same time from the same company. Wow. I’d love to know the company.
Christa DiBiase [00:31:19]: That’s terrible. But
Wes Moss [00:31:20]: that is a plot twist.
Christa DiBiase [00:31:22]: It is. But sounds like—
Wes Moss [00:31:23]: And then your, your CFP buddy who says you’re nowhere close to Coast Fire. I think that’s way off. I think he’s wrong.
Christa DiBiase [00:31:34]: Your buddy Wes says—
Wes Moss [00:31:36]: Your buddy Wes says, You are closer than your CFP friend is intimating. Now you’re in a high cost of living place. I know you said medium and high. I don’t know if you’re in New Jersey or New York, it can be really high. Um, and you got 2 kids, 9 and 7. That is a big— now, this is one of my main issues with Coast FIRE is, is kids. Now you already know you have 2 kids. Where you really get thrown off is you do Coast FIRE or FIRE and you end up and you have no kids and you end up with 2, 3, 4 kids, do that, throw that plan out the window.
Wes Moss [00:32:12]: But you’ve already got the kids. And here’s the other, Krystalina, here’s the 4% rule on $2 million is $80K. Mm-hmm. And your spending is only $80,000. So how are you not close to Coast FIRE? However, I would say I wouldn’t want to be turning on the 4% rule At age 45.
Christa DiBiase [00:32:36]: It doesn’t sound like they want to.
Wes Moss [00:32:37]: No, they, yeah, they are because they’re saying they can, the brokerage account can bridge them.
Christa DiBiase [00:32:44]: Oh, okay. Yeah. The brokerage, but they also said they’re going to cover their living expenses with part-time work.
Wes Moss [00:32:48]: Well, that’s the key. That is the key here is that the, the, here’s the 2 big variables. Uh, I would say school costs. If the kids all of a sudden have to go to private school, or you want to send them to the— that blows everything up. If they end up going to expensive private colleges, that blows everything up. But I’m sensing that you clearly are not going to private school because your total spending is only $80K.
Christa DiBiase [00:33:13]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:33:15]: And if you can lower the grind and cover the $80K, then yeah, that is the definition of Coast FI. And it sounds like it would be relatively easy for you guys to make $80K between the two of you. I bet you, I bet you, you can, I don’t know. You didn’t say what you were already earning. I’m suspecting it’s $300K and now you’re at zero. Can you land somewhere in the middle at $100K, $150K? If you do that and you don’t have to touch your assets and they can continue to grow for the next 20 years to get to 6, 10 years, get to 55, then there’s a very high chance that that is worth dramatically more. The, the 529 plan already probably covers a lot of college for the kids. Not all of it, but some.
Wes Moss [00:33:57]: Yeah. I think that your CFP friend is taking an extreme position. I don’t want to take the other extreme and say you don’t have to work. I’d say that the truth lies somewhere in the middle.
Christa DiBiase [00:34:09]: And I love that, taking your foot off the gas. Kids 9 and 7, they’re entering those years, as you know, Wes, when you then can spend a lot of time with them. If they’re doing sports or they’re their friends, you can get that quality time while before they’re like older teenagers and driving is probably Priceless.
Wes Moss [00:34:24]: You know what, the chart that always crushes me as a parent, we’ve— and now that I mentioned this, if you haven’t seen it, you’re gonna see it on social media somewhere, is the chart that shows, you know, it’s like every year is a block or every year is a month of your life.
Christa DiBiase [00:34:40]: Mm-hmm.
Wes Moss [00:34:41]: And it says how often you will see your kids or, or in reverse, how often you see your parents. And, you know, the first 18 years light up.
Christa DiBiase [00:34:51]: It’s
Wes Moss [00:34:51]: like, this is when you, and it’s like 96% of all your interaction with your parents or parents with your kids happens in the first 18 years. And then the other 4% spread out over the rest of their lives. Like, that’s a depressing chart to me.
Christa DiBiase [00:35:04]: Yeah. Yeah. So I’m living it. My daughter lives in another state now after college. It’s, yeah, it’s reality. So, well, good luck, whatever you decide, Kevin.
Wes Moss [00:35:15]: I think you’re closer than your friend suggests, but you’re not at the finish line.
Christa DiBiase [00:35:19]: Turning lemons into lemonade. which is awesome.
Wes Moss [00:35:23]: Chris, I love having you here. I love these questions. So thank you as always for being in studio. You can find me throughout the week. We’re at yourwealth.com. That’s Y-O-U-R, yourwealth.com. Have a wonderful rest of your day.
Disclosure [00:35:38]: Hey y’all, this is Mallory with the Retire Sooner team. Please be sure to rate and subscribe to this podcast and share it with a friend. If you have any questions, you can You can find us at wesmoss.com. That’s W-E-S-M-O-S-S.com. You can also follow us on Instagram and YouTube. You’ll find us under the handle Retire Sooner Podcast. And now for our show’s disclosure. This is provided as a resource for informational purposes and is not to be viewed as investment advice or recommendations.
Disclosure [00:36:05]: This information is being presented without consideration of the investment objectives, risk tolerance, or financial circumstances of any specific investor and might not be suitable for all investors. The mention of any company is provided to you for informational purposes and as an example only and is not to be considered investment advice or recommendation or an endorsement of any particular company. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. There is no guarantee offered that investment return, yield, or performance will be achieved. The information provided is strictly an opinion and for informational purposes only, and it is not known whether the strategies will be successful. There are many aspects and criteria that must be examined and considered before investing. This information is not intended to and should not form a primary basis for any investment decision that you may make.
Disclosure [00:36:52]: Always consult your own legal, tax, or investment advisor before making any investment, tax, estate, or financial planning considerations or decisions. Investment decisions should not be made solely based on information contained herein.
Call in with your financial questions for our team to answer: 800-805-6301
Join other happy retirees in our Retire Sooner Facebook Group
This information is provided to you as a resource for educational purposes and as an example only and is not to be considered investment advice or recommendation or an endorsement of any particular security. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. There is no guarantee offered that investment return, yield, or performance will be achieved. There will be periods of performance fluctuations, including periods of negative returns and periods where dividends will not be paid. Past performance is not indicative of future results when considering any investment vehicle. The mention of any specific security should not be inferred as having been successful or responsible for any investor achieving their investment goals. Additionally, the mention of any specific security is not to infer investment success of the security or of any portfolio. A reader may request a list of all recommendations made by Capital Investment Advisors within the immediately preceding period of one year upon written request to Capital Investment Advisors. It is not known whether any investor holding the mentioned securities have achieved their investment goals or experienced appreciation of their portfolio. This information is being presented without consideration of the investment objectives, risk tolerance, or financial circumstances of any specific investor and might not be suitable for all investors. This information is not intended to, and should not, form a primary basis for any investment decision that you may make. Always consult your own legal, tax, or investment advisor before making any investment/tax/estate/financial planning considerations or decisions.