What nearly a century of market history can teach us about single-day volatility, perspective, and building portfolios that last.
There is something about the holiday season that encourages reflection.
Thanksgiving brings family around the table. Hanukkah and Christmas bring gift exchanges, a few cups of holiday cheer, and, if your family is anything like mine, no shortage of opinions about everything from the flaws in the College Football Playoff to politics to the stock market.
And somewhere between cocktails and dessert, somebody inevitably asks: “So, where do you think the market will end up this year?”
I understand the question. Especially when the latest market decline is still fresh in everyone’s mind. But here is an important distinction: A single trading day tells you what happened that day. It does not tell you how the year will end.
I’m not in the business of offering predictions. What I can offer is perspective informed by nearly a century of market history, my engineering background, and a healthy appreciation for the difference between objective data and a subjective narrative.
Recently, I asked our investment team at Capital Investment Advisors to examine the frequency of significant daily market moves from 1928 through 2025.
And because three things are about the extent of my bandwidth these days, I’ll keep this to three observations.
1. Volatility Is a Feature, Not a Flaw
Turn on the financial news on a bad trading day, and you’ll hear plenty about the Dow Jones Industrial Average falling 300, 500, or even 1,000 points.
Those numbers look and sound frightening. But they lack context. As the Dow has grown over the decades, so has the number of points it moves on an average day. In percentage terms, however, the average daily movement has remained remarkably consistent.
A 374-point decline when the Dow is trading at 52,000 represents a 0.72% move. The same 374-point decline when the Dow was at 10,000 represented a 3.74% move. Same headline. Very different story.
In terms of points, the average daily move has grown from 1 point in the 1920s to 263 points in the 2020s. In percentage terms, the average daily move from 1918 through 2025 has been approximately 0.72%.
Our research into the S&P 500 revealed something equally interesting.
In a typical year, the market experiences approximately 55 trading days with a move of 1% or more, either up or down. That’s roughly one out of every five trading days. And about eight trading days in a typical year experience a move of 2% or more.
To put that in perspective:
- A 1% day happens about once a week.
- A 2% day happens about once every six weeks.
Think about that.
Something that happens approximately once a week should probably not qualify as an extraordinary event. Yet every time the market drops between 1 and 2%, the headlines make it sound like something has gone terribly wrong. Volatility isn’t a detour from the investing experience. It is part of the investing experience.
2. A Bad Day Does Not Make a Bad Year
This is where the research gets particularly interesting.
From 1928 through 2025, there were 79 calendar years in which the S&P 500 experienced at least one daily decline of approximately 2% or more. Of those 79 years, 54 still finished with a positive total return.
That’s 68%. Or as my colleague Eddie Goepp would say, “That’s almost 70%.” In other words, more than two out of every three years that experienced a significant one-day decline still finished with a positive total return.
Consider 2020. The pandemic brought the global economy to a virtual standstill. Businesses shuttered. Unemployment soared. Financial markets went into free fall. On March 16, the S&P 500 declined approximately 12% in a single trading session.
The market recorded 25 days with declines of 2% or more that year. And yet, by December 31, 2020, the S&P 500 had delivered a positive total return of approximately 18.4%.
Or consider 2009, when the market experienced 28 days with declines of 2% or more and still finished the year with a positive total return of approximately 26.5%.
That does not mean that every market decline ends happily. Some years are genuinely terrible, and losses can be substantial.
But it does illustrate an important distinction. 2009 and 2020 did not avoid bad days. They delivered positive returns despite them.
The reverse is also true. In 2022, the S&P 500 experienced 23 days with gains of 2% or more, yet the year finished down approximately 18.1%, including dividends.
One great day doesn’t guarantee a great year any more than one terrible day guarantees a terrible one. Perspective matters.
3. You Cannot Control the Weather. You Can Engineer for It.
Before entering wealth management, I was a structural engineer. I spent part of my career designing structures for coastal environments, where hurricanes weren’t hypothetical possibilities. They were an accepted risk.
I did not design buildings around the hope hurricanes would never hit. I designed them with the expectation that they would.
I think about retirement portfolios the same way. Markets will decline. Recessions will happen. Headlines will frighten people. And occasionally, the market will deliver the financial equivalent of a Category 5 hurricane.
The question isn’t whether we can avoid those events. The question is whether we’ve built a portfolio designed to help withstand them.
That’s the philosophy behind what I call The Dry Powder Principle.
At its core, the idea is relatively simple.
We believe Retirees who depend on their investments for income should maintain an appropriate reserve of cash, Treasury securities, and laddered investment-grade bonds to help cover spending needs when stocks are under pressure. That reserve doesn’t eliminate market risk, and it isn’t a guarantee against losses.
Maintaining a reserve involves trade-offs, including inflation risk, interest-rate and credit risks, and potentially lower returns than stocks. A reserve may also be insufficient during prolonged market downturns. But it can provide something valuable: time.
Time that allows markets the potential to recover without having to sell stocks at depressed prices simply to pay the bills. And time matters.
Consider another finding from our research, this time looking only at price returns (excluding dividends). A hypothetical $10,000 investment tracking the S&P 500’s price performance from the beginning of 1990 through the end of 2025 would have grown to $194,000. But if you missed just the ten best trading days over those 36 years, the ending value would have been less than half, approximately $86,000. Missing the worst days would have had the opposite effect, and no one can reliably identify either in advance.
And nine of those ten best days occurred during the financial crisis of 2008–2009 or the pandemic turmoil of 2020, within weeks of some of the market’s worst days.
The best days and the worst days have an unfortunate habit of showing up together.
This illustration assumes an initial investment of $10,000 tracking the price performance of the S&P 500 Index from January 1990 through December 2025. It excludes dividends, investment advisory fees, transaction costs, and taxes. The missed-best-days scenario assumes that the investor did not participate in the ten highest-return trading days during the period but otherwise remained invested. Past performance does not indicate future results.
That’s why attempting to sidestep every decline can be so dangerous. It’s also why I believe retirement planning should be about more than choosing investments.
It should be about engineering a portfolio that gives you the financial and emotional ability to remain invested through the inevitable storms.
A Little Perspective for the Holidays
As we gather with friends and family this holiday season, there will be plenty to worry about.
The economy. Interest rates. Elections. The next recession. Whether your team will ever make the College Football Playoff. Some of those concerns are legitimate.
But we shouldn’t confuse the noise of a single trading day with the direction of an entire financial future. Nearly a century of market history reminds us that volatility is normal, difficult days can coexist with rewarding years, and preparation is far more useful than prediction.
So when someone around the holiday table asks where the market will end the year, my answer will probably be the same as it has always been. I don’t know. But I’d rather spend my time building a portfolio that doesn’t require me to know. Because the goal isn’t to predict every storm. It’s to build something designed to withstand it.
The holiday season is a natural time to revisit your retirement plan. If recent market swings have you thinking about how your portfolio is positioned, let’s talk. Schedule a time to connect with our team, or send us your questions.
DEFINITIONS
Daily moves are close-to-close changes in the S&P price index, rounded to two decimal places before classification. A “big day” is a move of 1% or more in either direction. Individual bins cover 1.00–1.99%, 2.00–2.99%, and so on, with a final bin of 6.00% or more. Counts use calendar years. The daily S&P series begins in December 1927 and represents the S&P 90 until March 1957. “Typical year” refers to the median annual count for 1928–2025.
SOURCES
Daily closes: Bloomberg (SPX Index). Annual total returns: Bloomberg (SPXT Index) 1990–2025; Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern, 1928–1989. Recessions: NBER business cycle dates. Dow figures: Bloomberg (INDU Index), 1918–2025. For informational purposes only. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Specific years are shown for illustration and are not representative of all years.
Historical market data and illustrations are based on sources believed to be reliable but have not been independently verified. Indexes are unmanaged and cannot be invested in directly. Index performance does not reflect investment advisory fees, transaction costs, or other expenses. Historical index data may include predecessor index information.
This article is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or adopt any particular investment strategy. The views expressed are those of the author and are subject to change.
All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Diversification and maintaining cash or fixed-income reserves do not eliminate investment risk or guarantee against losses.